Despite all the negative reviews, I still grabbed this from Cosmo cosmetics for $5 last year. The colours looked great for the office and I stubbornly hoped it would work on me.
It didn't, but I thought I'd give it one last chance, before I dismiss it.
As expected it performed poorly on its own - it was faded and creased in just a couple of hours of wear. It didn't fare much better with primer (Too Faced Shadow Insurance) underneath. With primer underneath and powder eyeshadow on top, wear was more acceptable. But that would seem to defeat the quick-to-apply purpose of cream eyeshadows.
I should toss this, but somehow I can't bear to throw out a fairly new product even if it's unlikely I'll ever use it again. So I'll keep it in a box for now and if it never gets used again in a year's time, I'll toss it then.